Breaking the Cycle of Guilt: Embracing God’s Full Forgiveness
Why do Christians struggle with God’s forgiveness? It’s a question that cuts to the heart of what many believers wrestle with on a daily basis. Despite the promises of grace and freedom in scripture, countless people find themselves trapped in cycles of guilt, shame, and the constant need to “ask” God for forgiveness, even though the Bible assures us that it has already been fully given.
It’s not that they doubt God’s goodness; it’s that they often can’t grasp the magnitude of what has already been done for them. From generational misunderstandings to deeply ingrained religious practices, people often live with the haunting feeling that their sins are never fully dealt with.
But what if the key to breaking this cycle of insecurity and confusion lies in understanding the one-time, all-encompassing forgiveness Christ offers? The truth is that God’s forgiveness isn’t something to keep asking for—it’s something to receive, rest in, and walk confidently in.
What About Confession?
Confession, in its truest sense, is not about asking God for forgiveness repeatedly, as though His forgiveness is still in question. Instead, it’s an act of acknowledging our sins and bringing them before God, which can lead to healing and transformation.
However, confessing in order to “get” forgiveness, as if it’s something we must continually earn or seek, misses the reality that forgiveness has already been given through Christ.
Hebrews 10:26-27 warns that deliberately continuing in sin—which, in this context, refers to not fully believing in what Christ has already done for us—shows a disregard for God’s sacrifice and results in making a mockery of the cross. We are reminded that when we keep asking for forgiveness for what has already been forgiven, we undermine the sufficiency of Jesus’ once-for-all sacrifice.
This shift from endless asking to embracing and thanking God for His grace brings us into a deeper understanding of the freedom Christ has already provided.
So why do so many still struggle to embrace this gift? Let’s explore some of the key reasons this tension exists and how we can step into the freedom that Christ has already given us.
1. Ingrained guilt and shame: Many people have been taught to constantly feel guilty about their mistakes, often by others who do not fully understand that God has forgiven them completely. This misunderstanding gets passed down from generation to generation, like a disease that keeps affecting everyone who hasn’t yet encountered the truth of God’s grace. Until someone in a generation learns from the Spirit of God that their sins have been forgiven once and for all (Hebrews 7:27, 9:12, 9:26, 10:10), this cycle continues. Once a person comes to believe that God has truly taken away their sins—once and for all—this curse of ingrained guilt and shame can end. It’s about breaking free from this generational misunderstanding and embracing the truth that forgiveness is complete, not conditional or ongoing.
2. Misunderstanding the nature of grace: It’s part of our human nature to want to “work” to get results. We often feel like we need to do something in order to earn forgiveness or salvation. 1 Corinthians 2:12 teaches that the grace of God must be revealed to us by the Spirit, so we can truly understand what God has freely given us. What has God freely given us? Salvation, completely — and we cannot lose our salvation. We are forgiven completely, and there is no need to keep asking for forgiveness for what we already have. There are no conditions or “if’s” in God’s grace. The challenge is that this truth is difficult for people to grasp, which is why it must be revealed by the Spirit (1 Corinthians 2:10). It’s like we need to come to the end of our rope, where we finally surrender and realize that grace is not something we can earn or constantly ask for — it’s already been fully given to us. Coming to that realization takes a shift in understanding, which the Spirit alone can bring about.
3. Fear of consequences or an “insurance policy”: Some people might fear that if they don’t keep asking for forgiveness, they’re risking their relationship with God or that they might be judged. This fear can make them feel like they need to constantly seek forgiveness, even though the idea in many Christian teachings is that Jesus’ sacrifice already paid for all sins, past, present, and future. In a way, the repeated asking for forgiveness can act like an “insurance policy.” It’s almost as if people feel they need to keep asking for forgiveness just to be sure, just in case they missed something or didn’t fully repent in the right way. This can stem from a fear that if they don’t keep checking in with God, they might lose His favor or be at risk of judgment. It’s like trying to cover all bases, as if there’s a spiritual “loophole” they need to fill. The repeated asking can almost feel like a safety net, even though God’s forgiveness doesn’t depend on how many times we ask—it’s already been given.
4. Misunderstanding key scriptures:
- 1 John 1: Many people misunderstand 1 John 1:9 in the context of 1 John 1:8 and 1:10, which address the Gnostic problem of people claiming they have no sin or have not sinned. John is confronting those who deny sin, not suggesting a daily need to ask for forgiveness. 1 John 1:9 is saying that if we confess or agree that our sins have been taken away through Christ, Jesus is faithful to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. It’s about acknowledging that God has already forgiven and cleansed us, not about a constant request for forgiveness.
- Matthew 6 (The Lord’s Prayer): The confusion around Matthew 6 arises because people often don’t realize that this teaching came before the cross, when Jesus had not yet fully atoned for all sins. The Lord’s Prayer, including the request for forgiveness, should be understood in that pre-cross context. Also, the verses immediately following the Lord’s Prayer show a conditional forgiveness: “If you forgive your brother, God will forgive you; if you don’t, God won’t forgive you.” This is not true in the New Testament after Jesus’ sacrifice, where God has already taken away all your sins, regardless of whether you forgive others. In the New Covenant, forgiveness is complete and forever. 2 Corinthians 5:18 tells us that God is not counting our sins against us because of the finished work of Christ. After the cross, forgiveness is a done deal, and it’s not dependent on our actions. In the New Testament, God’s forgiveness is final and not conditional on our behavior.
- James 5:16: While James 5:16 encourages people to confess their sins to one another (which is a good practice for accountability and healing), it does not suggest that we need to confess our sins to God repeatedly. The focus is on mutual confession and prayer in the community, not seeking forgiveness from God in this particular verse.
5. Personal struggles with self-forgiveness: Often, the difficulty isn’t with God forgiving them, but with themselves. People might have trouble forgiving themselves for their actions, and that can make it harder for them to believe that God has already forgiven them. Many people who struggle with self-forgiveness are unknowingly setting their standard of forgiveness higher than God’s. Scripture clearly says that God has forgiven us completely, but when we refuse to forgive ourselves, we’re saying our standard for forgiveness is higher than God’s. In doing so, we deny the power of God’s grace and His forgiveness, which is freely given to us. Hebrews 10:26-27 warns that when we deliberately continue in sin—refusing to believe and receive the full sufficiency of Christ’s sacrifice—we are essentially making a mockery of the cross. Refusing to accept God’s forgiveness by holding on to guilt and shame suggests we’re rejecting the one-time, all-sufficient sacrifice that Jesus made for us. Learning to align our forgiveness with God’s standard is a key part of healing and growth in the Christian faith. When we reject God’s forgiveness by holding on to guilt and shame, we miss out on the freedom that Christ’s sacrifice has already secured for us.
6. Not understanding the New Covenant vs. the Old Covenant: Many people also struggle to grasp the distinction between the Old Covenant and the New Covenant. Under the Old Covenant, forgiveness often came through sacrifices and rituals that had to be repeated, and people were constantly reminded of their sins. But under the New Covenant, through Jesus’ sacrifice, forgiveness is once and for all. Hebrews 8:13 says the New Covenant has superseded the Old and made the former obsolete. Many Christians find themselves mixing the New and the Old Covenants, which leads to confusion. Paul addresses this in Galatians 1, warning that mixing the two is “no gospel at all.” In Galatians 3, he asks, “Who has bewitched you?” They began their faith journey with the grace of God, but now they’ve fallen back into a works-based mindset. This confusion between the Old and New Covenants leads people to live as if they are still under the law, constantly needing to ask for forgiveness, rather than understanding that Jesus’ sacrifice made forgiveness final and complete. It’s essential to understand that the New Covenant has replaced the Old, and that God’s forgiveness and grace are complete and eternal under the New Covenant.
7. Good can be the enemy of what is best: Sometimes, there are cultural or religious teachings that emphasize the act of repeatedly asking for forgiveness as a way of showing humility or repentance. However, this is where “good” can be the enemy of what is best. Asking God to forgive you over and over isn’t humility at all—it actually reveals pride. It shows that you have not fully accepted the one-time, all-sufficient sacrifice for your sins that Jesus has offered. In Hebrews, we are reminded that to keep asking for forgiveness repeatedly is to make a mockery of the cross, as if Christ’s sacrifice wasn’t enough. Asking God to forgive you over and over is not an act of faith, but presumption—presuming that God’s grace isn’t sufficient or that His forgiveness isn’t complete. When we continue to ask, we are essentially denying the power of the cross, failing to recognize that forgiveness is already given, once and for all.
A lot of this goes back to the core message that faith isn’t about what we do to earn forgiveness, but about accepting what’s already been given. Trusting in that forgiveness is a journey, but over time, it can bring a sense of peace and freedom. What do you think is the most challenging part of this concept for people?
Listen to these Grace Coach Podcasts
You Can Not Lose Your Salvation
Romans 5:1-11 – Salvation Defined
Romans 5:12-21 – Saved By His Resurrected Life
Help Us Tell The Whole World – Make a Donation to Grace Coach
